I was recently shown this comment by Daniel Joseph from a discussion of chapter 1 of Alien Phenomenology.
The thing that Ian is doing here is positing that philosophy can be practiced for the pure joy of things, as a way into the thing for it the thing itself. It is the application of the theory of OOO to OOO. Bryant, Bennett, Morton, Latour etc, they all are interested in OOO at least in some instrumental way. The ontology is that things are for themselves, but beyond the ontology, practice and epistemology comes back to how this philosophy can add to human understanding of Important Issues like ecology, the environment, political economy etc. Bogost is basically like "nuts to that! Yay things!!!!" which is both admirable AND scary!
This account may short-change Levi and Jane and Tim and Bruno (can I call him Bruno?) a bit, but it's an interesting take on the matter. Of course, we can have both: we can concern ourselves with Important Issues and we can also say nuts to that, sometimes at the same time. This is a perspective that some OOO critics can't quite see, and I do understand why; it's a mind-bender. But there's no reason why we can't simultaneously be humans concerned with human matters, humans concerned with toasters, and (if we really take seriously the plurality of "we") toasters concerned with sourdough.
On a related note, I have to admit, I didn't realize that Alien Phenomenology would be seen as taking such a radical position (radical in the sense of extreme, not in the sense of ... well, you know). Perhaps its the specificity... for example, the discussion of The Wire in the last chapter really rankles some readers.
The Electronic Book, circa 1995
The Walled Kindergarten
Seeing Ultraviolet
Object Lessons is coming...
Work With Me on Tinkering Platforms
Comments
carol on My Appearance on The Colbert Report
Darius K. on Seeing Ultraviolet
Katie King on The Electronic Book, circa 1995
Warren on The Electronic Book, circa 1995
Rumen on Object Lessons is coming...
The Curse of Cow Clicker
Beyond the Elbow-Patched Playground
Shit Crayons
Aerotropolis
Against Aca-Fandom
There are no Blown Calls in Football
We Think in Public
What is Object-Oriented Ontology?
The Metaphysics Videogame
Cascading Failure
Top Ten Reasons I Returned My Kindle
Carrying On Over Carry-Ons
Reading Online Sucks
Chumby and the Rhetoric of Openness







