Water Cooler Games
Water Cooler Games served as the web's primary forum for "videogames with an agenda" — coverage of the uses of video games in advertising, politics, education, and other everyday activities, outside the sphere of entertainment.

The site was maintained at watercoolergames.org from 2003-2009, where it was edited by myself and Gonzalo Frasca. It is now archived here in full.
Search Water Cooler Games:  
You are reading an archived version of this article. The original URL was (loading...)
A lousy environmental advergame
by Ian Bogost June 23, 2005

GPL PremierI've been traveling and attending conferences for more than a week, including DiGRA 2005 and Supernova 2005. I gave a paper at DiGRA on political games and a workshop talk at Supernova on games and advertising. More on those later. For now, it's time for a lousy environmental advergame.

French energy company Totalgaz has created an advergame to promote their GPL Premier fuel (site in French), which offers the dreamy promise of costing less, polluting less while still "preserving your driving pleasure." The game is also couched as a contest with several prizes, including year of free fuel, a vacation, and €20 fuel vouchers.

Now, the combination of cost, pollution, and driving pleasure are really the makings of a terrific videogame. Typically one has to balance cost against performance, and performance against pollution, and I can imagine a handful of game designs that might take advantage of this core mechanic. Most notably, it would be interesting to have to use limited funds to choose between different fuels, each of which would provide different combinations of pollutants and performance. This way, the player would really see the tradeoffs between fuel cost, clean air, and vehicle performance. If GPL Premier really does what it says, the advantages would be palpable.

GPL LogoOf course, that's not the game they made. Instead, in typical advertising agency fashion, Totalgaz and agency Crossvalue made this GPL Premier game. The game represents a city with cars congesting the streets. A grey sheen over the city indicates how polluted it is. The gameplay is simply absurdist, almost a satire of the worst kind of contemporary advertising. The player uses a pair of binoculars to search around the city looking for -- wait for it -- GPL Premier logos! Logos! I wish I were kidding, but you can see the proof in the screenshot detail inset at right. That's the entire game. If you find all six logos, you get 3 credits toward the prize giveaway. Even worse is the setup for the game:

Sauvez la ville grâce au GPL Premier!
La situation est grave
la ville se dégrade
mais vous pouvez nous aider!

God save us from the advertisers.

(via Adverblog)

Comments (4)
I saw links for the Totalgaz advergame start appearing earlier this week, but I never got the chance to give it a try until now. I have to say that I agree 100% with Ian over on Water Cooler Games. This is the worst kind of advergame, and does nothin...

Ian, I couldn't agree with you more on this (as I just noted in our blog http://www.fuelgames.com/blog/?p=38 )

These types of games are the worst type of advergames. They do nothing to incorporate the brand, and it isn't even a very fun game. It's not even as good as slapping a logo on a fun action-puzzle knockoff.

My biggest problem with this type of work is that if too many agencies start pushing these "solutions" then brands are going to get turned off from what has the potential to be an incredibly effecting marketing medium.

Unfortunately, it seems too many agencies are already pushing these kinds of solutions. Damn you all, you advertising agencies!

Seriously. I mean it's not surprising really. Look at the advertising on your tv. It's not cinema. Ad agencies are where good ideas go to hide and die.

Thank god there's still independent developers!